Wednesday 18 September 2019 ,
Wednesday 18 September 2019 ,
Latest News
  • Nursing education to be upgraded: PM
  • Open your eyes: UN envoy to Suu Kyi
  • Trump to meet Imran, Modi for talks focusing on Kashmir
  • Bangladesh to seek expeditious global efforts to resolve Rohingya crisis
  • Dhaka ranks 7th worst in Air Quality Index
  • 536 new dengue patients hospitalised in 24 hrs: DGHS
19 August, 2019 00:00 00 AM

What exactly is a disease?

Yahoo News
What exactly is a disease?
Not all disease is easy to spot. Yok_onepiece/Shutterstock

DUANE MELLOR

There is an ongoing lively debate among healthcare professionals about whether or not obesity is a disease. Differences between those who argue that it’s a disease and those who argue that it’s just a risk factor for conditions such as type 2 diabetes and heart disease are unlikely to be resolved any time soon. The debate, however, raises other questions, such as, what exactly is a disease and who gets to decide?

A simple definition of disease is an “illness or sickness characterised by specific signs or symptoms”. But it is interesting that some dictionaries suggest that diseases are caused by “bacteria or infections”, seemingly dismissing psychological and noncommunicable conditions as diseases, which is odd given that noncommunicable diseases, such as cardiovascular disease and cancer, make up most ill health in the world today.

Official catalogue of disease

On a global level, diseases are catalogued by international groups of experts for the World Health Organisation (WHO). This catalogue, the International Classification of Disease, is now in its tenth revision (ICD-10).

Despite its name, the classification doesn’t stop at diseases but includes related health problems, which may be linked to a particular disease, or may be a symptom as part of a syndrome or even a consequence of a medical procedure. For example, even dehydration appears in ICD-10, where it is also called “volume depletion”.

So perhaps there is not even agreement on what is meant by disease. And what is classified as disease is essentially down to expert consensus.

While the WHO doesn’t seem to have a clear definition of disease, it does at least have a definition of health. It is defined as “a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity”.

The definition of health appears to be broad and inclusive, but defining disease appears to be more challenging than defining its opposite. Few people would disagree that measles, say, is a disease. But what happens when society decides to classify a certain human behaviour or characteristic, which some groups happen to find disturbing, as a disease.

Sin as a source of disease

Examples of classifying characteristics as diseases can be seen throughout human history.

Many of these might be grounded in traditional beliefs and views of health, disease and their links to sin.

The development of psychology as a science potentially led some perceived “sins” to be translated into mental health disorders. Perhaps the best example of this is homosexuality. Homosexuality was classified as a mental disorder by the American Psychiatric Association (APA) in 1968.

This was later challenged by a vote among APA members in 1973, where a majority of 58% chose to remove it from the diagnostic manual. Homosexuality was not fully removed from the diagnostic manual for another decade and is now considered to be a normal characteristic within the diversity of human nature.

This disturbing episode raises further questions: on what basis and in whose interests are diseases classified?

In 2013, researchers at Bond University in Australia looked at who gets to classify diseases. They found that common diseases often had their definitions widened by expert groups, without considering the potential risks or challenges of increasing the number of people living with disease. They also noted that experts who widened definitions of diseases often have conflicts of interests in the form of funding from pharmaceutical companies.

On the spectrum

Sometimes, risk factors for a disease – such as high blood pressure – eventually get defined as a disease in their own right. And once these risk factors are reclassified as a disease, their targets or ranges tend to shift over time, increasing the number of people who have the disease. For example, high blood pressure used to be anything over 140/90. But in 2017, the US changed the threshold to 120/80.

Distinguishing a disease from a risk factor is not easy, especially when it comes to chronic diseases, which tend to be a spectrum from health to illness. Blood glucose (sugar) is a clear example as levels move from healthy through pre-diabetes into type 2 diabetes. So spotting where health finishes and disease begins is difficult, to the point that the WHO and International Diabetes Federation suggest there is no such thing as a normal level of blood glucose.

Nevertheless, the definition of gestational diabetes (diabetes in pregnancy) changed in 2014, when the blood glucose threshold was lowered. The change increased the incidence of gestational diabetes by 74% with no improvement in short-term outcomes, such as the mother needing a caesarean section, according to one Australian study.

Many clinicians are critical of this trend, calling it over-medicalisation.

Normal ageing or disease?

Sometimes, conditions previously thought of as being a natural part of getting older have become diseases. For example, osteoporosis was considered a normal part of ageing until 1994 when the WHO officially recognised it as a disease.

Given osteoporosis’s link with an increased risk of fractures and the devastating impact broken bones can have on the elderly, this seems like a change in definition that is justified.

Other physiological changes that occur in older age, such as a fall in testosterone levels in men, may not benefit from disease status. But that hasn’t stopped some healthcare experts trying to create a new condition called “the andropause”. So far, though, resistance to recognising this change as a disease has been strong.

All of the above goes to show that deciding what is or isn’t a disease is not easy, but hopefully you’ll be better equipped to ask some critical questions such as, who benefits from this new definition? And do they have my best interests at heart? The answer to the latter question is usually yes – but not always.

Courtesy: The Conversation

Comments

Most Viewed
Digital Edition
More story
Editor Speaks

Editor Speaks

Communication between organs to organs is vital and this is done by a chemical messenger comprising feedback loops of hormones released by internal organs…
How to keep your legs healthy?

How to keep your legs healthy?

In this fast changing world, you will be hearing quite often your family members especially in their fifties complaining now and then about all kinds…
What are hormones?

What are hormones?

A hormone is a chemical released by one or more cells that affects cells in other parts of the organism. Only a small amount of hormone is required to…
What to know about hormonal imbalances

What to know about hormonal imbalances

Hormonal imbalances occur when there is too much or too little of a hormone in the bloodstream. Because of their essential role in the body, even small…
Adrenal fatigue is the root of many illnesses

Adrenal fatigue is the root of many illnesses

ALEX HOWARD The adrenal glands sit on top of the kidneys and produce a number of hormones such as adrenalin, noradrenalin, cortisol and DHEA. These hormones…
Andropause

Andropause

Andropause, also sometimes called male menopause, is an acquired type of hypogonadism caused by the gradual decline of testosterone levels as a result…
Can gut bacteria affect how we store fat?

Can gut bacteria affect how we store fat?

DARLA LEAL Gut bacteria or microbes live in our digestive tract helping us digest food, prevent infection, and shown to play a role in our physical fitness.…
How old is too old to go to the pediatrician?

How old is too old to go to the pediatrician?

For most parents, getting started with a pediatrician is the easy part. Chances are that even before you gave birth, you had researched doctors certified…
Britain slumps to bottom of cancer survival league tables – and is two decades behind some countries

Britain slumps to bottom of cancer survival league tables – and is two decades behind some countries

 LAURA DONNELLY   Britain is bottom of international league tables for cancer survival – and is lagging two decades behind some countries…
Hypertension: The No. 1 sign you have high blood pressure

Hypertension: The No. 1 sign you have high blood pressure

KORIN MILLER  Hypertension is known as the “silent killer” and it’s not something that you want to mess with. One in three Americans…
Prof. Dr. Afzal performed the first  zero-contrast angioplasty  in Bangladesh

Prof. Dr. Afzal performed the first zero-contrast angioplasty in Bangladesh

Zero-contrast angioplasty was done, for the first time in Bangladesh, on 30 July 2019 in the National Institute of Cardiovascular Diseases (NICVD). Prof.…
Heavy menstrual bleeding: Keyhole hysterectomy technique 'more effective'

Heavy menstrual bleeding: Keyhole hysterectomy technique 'more effective'

A keyhole-surgery technique for treating heavy menstrual bleeding is more effective and just as safe as a non-invasive alternative, a study of more than…
Full chemo doses may improve survival in breast cancer

Full chemo doses may improve survival in breast cancer

Maintaining full doses of chemotherapy, especially early in the treatment course, is important for survival of intermediate or high-risk breast cancer…
Anti-addiction meds can help teen Opioid abusers

Anti-addiction meds can help teen Opioid abusers

The epidemic of opioid addiction and abuse ravaging the United States is also affecting teenagers. Now, research confirms that anti-addiction medications…

Copyright © All right reserved.

Editor : M. Shamsur Rahman

Published by the Editor on behalf of Independent Publications Limited at Media Printers, 446/H, Tejgaon I/A, Dhaka-1215.
Editorial, News & Commercial Offices : Beximco Media Complex, 149-150 Tejgaon I/A, Dhaka-1208, Bangladesh. GPO Box No. 934, Dhaka-1000.

Editor : M. Shamsur Rahman
Published by the Editor on behalf of Independent Publications Limited at Media Printers, 446/H, Tejgaon I/A, Dhaka-1215.
Editorial, News & Commercial Offices : Beximco Media Complex, 149-150 Tejgaon I/A, Dhaka-1208, Bangladesh. GPO Box No. 934, Dhaka-1000.

Disclaimer & Privacy Policy
....................................................
About Us
....................................................
Contact Us
....................................................
Advertisement
....................................................
Subscription

Powered by : Frog Hosting