Sunday 22 July 2018 ,
Sunday 22 July 2018 ,
Latest News
  • Terrifying situation in 3 cities ahead of polls: Rizvi
  • Mahmudur hospitalized after ‘BCL’ attack in Kushtia
  • Rajshahi BNP leader held over crude bomb attack at rally
  • Next polls to be held as per constitution: Quader
  • Army plays supportive role in establishing democracy: PM
  • 4 killed in Rangpur road crash
1 March, 2018 00:00 00 AM
Print

Implications for the reform of the criminal justice system of Bangladesh

The government has a weighty responsibility to ensure fair administration of justice
SADIYA S. SILVEE
Implications for the reform of the criminal justice system of Bangladesh

The right to a fair trial, which is also called ‘fair administration of justice’, is one of the cornerstones of a democratic society abiding by the ‘rule of law’. Although the Constitution of Bangladesh, in the preamble, pledged to secure a socialist society ‘in which the rule of law, fundamental human rights and freedom, equality, and justice, political, economic and social, will be secured for all citizens’, it has excluded ‘right to a fair trial’. However, the Constitution has specifically guaranteed one's rights to equality before the law [Article 27], to enjoy the protection of the law and to be treated 'in accordance with law' [Article 31] and to consult and be defended by a legal practitioner of his choice [Article 33]. Predominantly, in Article 35 it has guaranteed certain rights which are the components of ‘right to a fair trial’, such as the right to 'a speedy and public trial by an independent and impartial court or tribunal', ‘right to be secured from double jeopardy’, right to non self-discrimination and protection against ‘torture or to cruel, inhuman, or degrading punishment or treatment’. In dilettante’s terms, it is not important to acknowledge ‘right to a fair trial’ explicitly in our Constitution when it acknowledges the components in many of its provisions.

In an adversary criminal system, which Bangladesh adhere to, is based on the accusatorial method. Under this system, the charges against an accused are presented before an open court supported by evidence, which is subjected to challenge, and the proceedings are concluded by a reasoned judgment of the court. This means iuspuniendi, ‘the right to punish’, rests firmly with the court when the guilt is proved beyond any reasonable doubt. Hence, the government has to play the key role of holding people accountable for the crimes they have committed and to ensure that justice is done not only from the victim’s side but also from the accused side. Hence, a government has a grave responsibility to ensure ‘a fair administration of justice’. Absences of ‘Right to a fair trial’ in the Constitution do not mean we don’t have the right, but it means there is no remedy if the right gets violated. For which it is important to acknowledge ‘Right to a fair trial’ in the Constitution. One might argue Article 35 of our Constitution resembles ‘Right to a fair trial’. Does ‘right to a fair trial’ mean only Article 35 of our Constitution? Or, it includes the rights guaranteed under Article 27, 31 33? Or, it’s beyond? The International law as enumerated by Article 38 of the ICJ Statute along with our national laws such as, the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act 1973 [hereinafter referred to as ICTA] and the International Crimes Tribunal Rules of Procedure, 2010 [hereinafter referred to as ICTR] can navigate us in this regard.

1.    Right to be brought promptly before a judge[Section 167(1) &Section 61CrPC; Article 9(3)  & Article 9(5)  ICCPR]    

2.    Right to trial by a competent, independent and impartial tribunal established by law [Section 6(2A) ICTA; Article 10 UDHR; Article 14(1) ICCPR; UN General Assembly resolutions 67/166, preamble §11 and 65/213, preamble §9].

3.    Right to be presumed innocent [Rule 43(2) ICTR;Article 11 of the UDHR; Article 14(2) ICCPR;HRC: General Comment 24, §8]

4.    Right to adequate time and facilities to prepare a defence [Rule 38(2) ICTR; Article 14(3)(b) of the ICCPR; HRC General Comment 32, §32.]

5.    Right to protection against self-incrimination [Rule 43(7) ICTR;Article 14(3)(g) of the ICCPR]

6.    Right to examine Witness Evidence [Section 9(4), Section 17(3) & Section 18(4) ICTA ;Article 14(3)(e) ICCPR;Article 6(3)(d) ECHR]

7.    Prohibition of prosecution on frivolous charges [Rule 29(1) ICTA; Crain v. Commissioner, 737 F.2d 1417 (1984);Washington v. Alaimo934 F. Supp. 1395 (S.D. Ga. 1996)]

8.    Right to bail if investigation is not completed within a specifiedperiod [Rule 9(5); HitendraVishu Thakur v. State of Maharashtra1994 AIR 2623, 1994 SCC (4) 602]

9.    Rights to humane detention conditions and freedom from torture and other ill-treatment [Rule 16(2) ICTR; Principle 5 of the Basic Principles for the Treatment of Prisoners]

10    Right to inspect documents [Section 16(2) ICTA; Rule 77 & 78 Rules of ICC]

11.    Right to have proper legal representation  [Section 17(2), Section 12 & Rule 43 (1) ICTA; Rule 22 Rules of ICC;HRC General Comment 32, §34;Article 16(4) of the Arab Charter]

12.    Right to conduct own defence [Section 17(2) ICTA; Article 11(1) UDHR; Article 14(3)(d) ICCPR]

13.    Right of the accused to explain charges [Section 16&Section 17(1) ICTA; Article 61 Rome Statute ICC]

14.    Right to call their own defence witnesses [Section 10(1)(f) & Section 17(3) ICTA; Article 14(3)(e) ICCPR]

15.    Right of the victims and witnessto be protected[Rule 58A ICTR; HRC General Comment 32;A.S. v Finland (40156/07), (2010) §55,]

16.    Burden of Proof on prosecution beyond reasonable doubt [Rule 50 ICTR; Section N(6)(e)(i) of the Principles on Fair Trial in Africa;HRC General Comment 32, §30; Barberà, Messegué and Jabardo v Spain (10590/83) (1988) §77)

17.    Right to speedy trial [Rule 43(5) ICTR;Article 14(3)(c) of the ICCPR]

18.    Protection against double jeopardy [Rule 43(3) ICTR;Article 14(7) of the ICCPR]

19.    Right to know the reasons for the judgment[HRC General Comment 32, §29]

20.    Right to have a sentencing hearing [Article 4(2) of the Convention against Torture]

21.    Right to appeal and review against both conviction and sentence [Section 21(1) ICTA; Rule 26 (3) ICTR;Article 14(5) ICCPR.

After exploring the other rights that emerge from the ‘Right to a fair trial’, we can fathom the importance of acknowledging ‘Right to a fair trial’ in our Constitution.Some might put forward Article 7B of our Constitution. Does it say we can’t amend Part III of our Constitution? The Constitutional guarantee isthe baseline for rights and it allows legal protection of that standard. Such an amendment will enhance our trial system, and without it the Bangladesh will be that one country left behind.

The writer is a Research Assistant, Death Penalty Research Project (DPRP) at Bangladesh Institute of Law and International affairs (BILIA)

 

Comments

Poll
Today's Question »
Dhaka wants UNSC to deliver on Rohingya issue as the powerful council sits tomorrow. Do you think it’ll be able to take any effective measure?
 Yes
 No
 No Comment
Yes 80.6%
No 16.1%
No Comment 3.2%
Most Viewed
Digital Edition
Archive
SunMonTueWedThuFri Sat
01020304050607
08091011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031
More Editorial stories
Indian army chief’s uncalled for remarks Indian army chief  General Bipin Rawat’s statement that Bangladesh was being used for ‘proxy war’ by Pakistan with the help of China is absolutely uncalled for and will not do any…

Copyright © All right reserved.

Editor : M. Shamsur Rahman

Published by the Editor on behalf of Independent Publications Limited at Media Printers, 446/H, Tejgaon I/A, Dhaka-1215.
Editorial, News & Commercial Offices : Beximco Media Complex, 149-150 Tejgaon I/A, Dhaka-1208, Bangladesh. GPO Box No. 934, Dhaka-1000.

Editor : M. Shamsur Rahman
Published by the Editor on behalf of Independent Publications Limited at Media Printers, 446/H, Tejgaon I/A, Dhaka-1215.
Editorial, News & Commercial Offices : Beximco Media Complex, 149-150 Tejgaon I/A, Dhaka-1208, Bangladesh. GPO Box No. 934, Dhaka-1000.

Disclaimer & Privacy Policy
....................................................
About Us
....................................................
Contact Us
....................................................
Advertisement
....................................................
Subscription

Powered by : Frog Hosting